Not once during the whole war did pope pius xii mention nazis or jews, much less condemn hitlers regime. In hitler, the war and the pope ronald rychlak, a law professor, seeks to refute the allegation that pius xii supported the nazi genocide of europes jews. The vindication of pius xii has been established principally by jewish writers and from israeli archives. Specifically, could pope pius xii have curbed the holocaust by vigorously condemning the nazi killing of jews. Collaborative effort by a number of the worlds leading experts on the holocaust. This book was edited by gary krupp who is jewish and has numerous documents and sources which vindicate pope pius xii. Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel.
I believe that there were several rabbis in his family. The scarlet and the black tv movie 1983 the scarlet. Pope pius xiis response to the roman razzia italian for roundup or mass deportation of jews on october 16, 1943 is a significant issue relating to pope pius xii and the holocaust. Now a british author has unearthed extensive material that vatican. Pope pius xii has been unfairly blamed over the past fifty years for not having denounced hitler publicly. The move could allow historians to shed light on the actions of pius xii during world war ii, in particular claims that his. During his reign as pope, the papacy confronted the ravages of world war ii.
This revelatory account of how the vatican saved thousands of jews during wwii shows why history must exonerate hitlers pope accused of being silent during the holocaust, pope pius xii and the vatican of world war ii are now exonerated in gordon thomass newest investigative work, the popes jews. Dalin a new authentically jewish history of pope pius xii and the holocaust needs to be written in order to help bring some longoverdue recognition to this righteous gentile, a man whose legacy is. This book was based on careful historical research of vatican documents and reflected 12 volumes that were carefully examined between 19651981. Gordon thomas a revelatory account of the vaticans efforts to save thousands of jewish people during world war ii refutes beliefs about pius xiis neutrality. Pope francis says pius xiis beatification wont go ahead. The vaticans secret plan to save jews from the nazis is a 2012 book by the british author gordon thomas concerning the efforts of pope pius xii to protect jews during the nazi holocaust. Why pius ix might be the most important pope in modern church history pius ix became head of the catholic church in 1846 and instituted the doctrine of papal infallibility. The observer reported in 20 that gordon thomas, a protestant, was given access to previously unpublished vatican documents and tracked down victims, priests and others who had not told their stories before and had uncovered evidence on pius xiis wartime efforts to save jewish refugees. This entry was posted in apologetics, catholic mthys refuted and tagged catholic church hitler, catholic church nazis, did pope help jews, pius xii, pope and the holocaust, pope nazi, pope nazis, pope pius 12, pope pius xii, pope pius xii and the holocaust, pope pius xii and the jews, pope world war ii. Pius xii protested at diplomatic levels, while several thousand jews found refuge in catholic networks, in. Pope pius xii blesses the us troops after liberation of. Oclcs webjunction has pulled together information and resources to assist library staff as they consider how to handle coronavirus. Pope francis to allow access to holocaustera documents of pius xii.
Now consider protestants like corrie tenbaum and her family who risked their lives to hide jews. The role of the papacy in world war ii is the ultimate example of the pitfalls of historians fallacy. Under mussolini, no policy of abduction of jews had been implemented in italy. There is no place of sorrow where the spirit of love of pius xii has not reached. The world war ii record of the jews and the catholic church in italy shows that pope pius xii, through his network of apostolic delegates throughout the world, was able to save the lives of thousands of jews, including those who did not convert to catholicism, during the holocaust. A film on pope pius xii blessing the us troops after liberation of rome. During the nazi occupation of rome september, 1943 to june, 1944, pius xii helped to raise the gestapo s demand of 50 kilos of gold from the jewish community for their safety. Pope pius xii, after building the nazi war machine, saw hitler losing his battle against russia, and he immediately jumped to the other side when he saw the handwriting on the. Unsealed records of pope pius xii could shed light on vaticans turbulent postwar years. A number of other scholars replied with favourable accounts of pius xii, including margherita marchiones yours is a precious witness. Pope pius xiis response to the roman razzia or mass deportation of jews on october 16, 1943 is a significant issue relating to pope pius xii and the holocaust. Following the capitulation of italy in 1943, nazi forces invaded and occupied much of the country, and began deportations of jews to. Gery krupp and his editors have digitized approximately 65%. Unfortunately, the payment did not prevent the eventual roundup of jews.
Pierre blets pius xii and the second world war, according to the archives of the vatican 1999. Do catholics really expect us to believe that pius was more godly because of a temporal title not even recognized in the bible. In this rebuttal to cornwell and other critics, thomas recounts the period of maximum danger for the vatican during wwii, from september 1943 to june 1944, when german forces occupied rome, and hitler sought to kidnap the pope. Lively, but not sensationalistic, this book is balanced but on the cutting edge of one of the most important debates in this field. Did pope pius xii do anything to help jews during wwii. The real story of pius xii and the jews by james bogle jewish dauchaus priests the weekly standard. Rabbi israel zolli was the chief rabbi of trieste for many years 35, i think before coming to rome. Pope pius xi, to his credit, publicly opposed authoritarian communism, nazism, and italian fascism the year before the outbreak of. He corroborates everything that avro manhattan said in. During and after the war, many wellknown jews albert einstein, moshe sharett, rabbi isaac herzog, and innumerable others publicly expressed their gratitude to pius. Readers should follow this book by the book titled pope pius xii and world war iithe docuemented truth. Kings and emperors allowed and encouraged mob violence against the jews, and it was often the popes who protected them, even excommunicating any christian who took part in the riots. The bestknown piusbashing title is hitlers pope, by john cornwell 1999. The conference results were presented to cardinal dominique.
I understand that the chief rabbi of rome, rabbi israel zolli was a devout and serious orthodox jew as well as a learned scholar of the talmud and of semitic literature. Why pius ix might be the most important pope in modern. Falsely accused of having remained silent during the holocaust, pope pius xii did more than any other human being to save jews. This book by a roman catholic writer is just in time for reformation day. New evidence emerging that disproves image of pius xii as hitlers pope. The single most controversial element of recent catholic history has to be the relationship between pope pius xii and the jews.
After the war the chief rabbi of israel thanked pius xii for what he had done. Although the city of rome was occupied by germany from 1943 and the allies from 1944, vatican city itself was not occupied. After world war ii, many jewish leaders openly thanked. Following the capitulation of italy in 1943, nazi forces invaded and occupied much of the country, and began deportations of jews to extermination camps. Pius ii, outstanding italian humanist and astute politician who as pope reigned 145864 tried to unite europe in a crusade against the turks at a time when they threatened to overrun all of europe. The popes jews the vaticans secret plan to save jews from the nazis book. Not least among many tributes to pope pius and his wartime advocacy for the jews of europe was this one by rabbi israel zolli, romes chief rabbi during world war ii. Pius xii, original name eugenio maria giuseppe giovanni pacelli, born march 2, 1876, rome, italydied october 9, 1958, castel gandolfo, pope, bishop of rome and head of the roman catholic church, who had a long, tumultuous, and controversial pontificate 193958. Suggesting that pius was responsible for this, thomas presents an earnest defense while sketching romes menacing atmosphere during the nazi occupation. Hitlers pope the secret history of pius xii excerpts. Booklist on the popes jews gordon thomass new book.
June 17, 2008 a vatican representative on tuesday expressed regret that some 15 israeli archives do not allow access to documents relating to pope pius xii and his attitude during the holocaust. No effort is made to place events in their context. Longburied vatican files reveal a new and shocking indictment of world war ii s pope plus xii. Pius xii, european fascism, and the vaticans wwii records. In all, pope pius xii directly assisted 63,04 percent of the jews in rome, or twothirds the 9,975 jews there during the nazi years. According to the archives of the vatican which was published in 1997 and translated into english in 1999. By the end of world war ii, he would be roundly praised for his defense of human rights, including his. Pius xii has long been vilified as hitlers pope, accused of failing publicly to condemn the genocide of europes jews. The charity and work of pope pius xii during world war ii so impressed the chief rabbi of rome, israel zolli, that in 1944 he was open to the grace of god which led him into the catholic faith. While acknowledging pope pius xiis reluctance to challenge fascism during the second world war. Numerous and frequentlyupdated resource results are available from this search. It is a defense pleading in which specific charges are refuted. The usefulness of daniel goldhagen his new book attacking pope pius xii is filled with factual errors, providing an opportunity for other anticatholic writers to claim the middle ground the good samaritan. Friend and rescuer of jews, which was published in the january 2012.
That is, the gift of hindsight makes the decisions and decisionmaking process seem counterintuitive or deplorable in a manner that isnt con. Pope pius xii has been unfairly blamed over the past fifty years. Unsealed records of pope pius xii could shed light on. Pope pius xii and the raid on the roman ghetto wikipedia. The vaticans secret plan to save jews from the nazis, by gordon thomas. Vatican city pursued a policy of neutrality during world war ii, under the leadership of pope pius xii. Pius nonetheless acted on an individual basis to save many jews and others with church ransoms, documents, and asylum. When pius died in 1958, the chief rabbi of rome, elio toaff, said jews will always remember what the catholic church did for them by order of the pope during the second world war. This was happening with the full knowledge of people within the vatican, including the pope. Pope pius xii and the holocaust evangelization station. Memoirs of jews and catholics in wartime italy 1997, pope pius xii.
Thomass careful research into new, firsthand accounts reveal an underground network. Researcher reveals pius xiis remarkable aid for jewish. Indeed, in the early years of the war, pope pius was one of the few world leaders who took on hitler and the nazis. At first i thought the title of this book was a bit strong. Pope pius xii and the jews catholic education resource. Pope pius xii blesses the us troops after liberation of rome, in roman catholic church in vatican city, italy, during wwii. Holocaust survivors announce symposium on pius xiis work to save jews during wwii. It is now established that the pope supervised a rescue network which saved 860,000 jewish lives more than all the international agencies put together.
What was pope pius xiis role in saving the jews during. Thomass careful research into new, firsthand accounts reveal an underground network of. Architect for peace 2000 and consensus and controversy. Why did the chief rabbi of rome convert to catholicism. Pope francis says pius xiis beatification wont go ahead wwii era pontiff accused by jewish groups of not speaking out against holocaust or helping local community. While some catholics zealously killed jews during wwii, others, like the holy father of the time, pope pius xii, remained silent. Pair this title with ralph mcinerneys defamation of pius xii 2001. New evidence emerging that disproves image of pius xii as. Researcher reveals pius xiis remarkable aid for jewish refugees.
151 139 292 1277 1190 109 950 1230 1398 831 909 929 1305 1261 1405 1458 200 40 1533 705 722 126 162 902 186 240 794 855 567 312 791